Written by Concussions in youth sports have become a significant concern in recent years, with increasing awareness of their potential long-term effects on young athletes. This issue requires careful attention from parents, coaches, and medical professionals to ensure the safety and well-being of young participants in various sports.
Understanding Concussions in Youth Sports
Concussions are a form of traumatic brain injury caused by a blow, bump, or jolt to the head that disrupts normal brain function. In youth sports, these injuries can occur in a wide range of activities, with higher risks in contact sports like football, wrestling, and martial arts.
Incidence and Risk Factors
The overall incidence of concussions among youth athletes is approximately 12.1%. Several factors contribute to an increased risk of concussions:
- Age: 18-year-old athletes have almost twice the risk of concussion compared to 13-year-olds.
- Gender: In comparable sports, girls have a 1.5 times higher concussion risk than boys.
- Concussion History: Athletes with a prior concussion have a 3-5 times greater risk of sustaining another concussion.
The Challenge of Prevention
It’s crucial to understand that there is no foolproof way to prevent concussions entirely in sports. The dynamic nature of athletic activities and the unpredictability of collisions or falls make it impossible to eliminate the risk completely. Moreover, there is no proven data to support that adding padding to the outside of a helmet can help reduce concussions. Despite this, certain measures can be taken to reduce the likelihood of concussions:
- Proper technique training
- Appropriate protective equipment
- Enforcement of fair play rules
- Awareness and education for athletes, coaches, and parents
Research has shown that even aftermarket helmet add-on devices, such as soft coverings intended to mitigate energy transfer, have failed to significantly improve helmets’ ability to reduce impact forces at most locations. In fact, a study on one such device found that it did not alter impact severity on a helmet drop-testing battery for both Gadd Severity Index and peak linear acceleration measurements.
Ongoing Research and Development
While current helmet technologies have limitations, researchers continue to explore innovative solutions. For example, a team at Stanford University is developing a football helmet lined with 21 liquid shock absorbers. Tests on a model of this helmet showed it could potentially reduce the severity of concussive and subconcussive impacts by 33% compared to existing popular models.However, it’s important to note that while technological advancements in helmet design are promising, they are just one part of a multi-pronged approach needed to address the issue of concussions in youth sports. Other crucial elements include:
- Rule changes promoting safer gameplay
- Constant head impact monitoring
- Improved education for athletes, coaches, and training staff
- Better diagnostic tools and protocols for concussion assessment
Helmet Weight and Neck Strength Considerations
An often overlooked aspect of youth football safety is the relationship between helmet weight and a young player’s neck strength. Youth football helmets typically weigh between 3 to 5 pounds, which may not seem significant for adults but can be challenging for young athletes to support.
Impact of Helmet Weight on Youth Players
The average youth football player may lack the neck strength to adequately support the weight of a standard helmet, potentially leading to:
- Increased fatigue during play
- Reduced range of motion
- Difficulty maintaining proper head position
These factors can contribute to poor tackling technique and potentially increase the risk of injury.
Benefits of Strength Training
Implementing appropriate strength training programs can be beneficial for youth football players. Proper strength training can:
- Improve neck strength and stability
- Enhance overall body control and coordination
- Potentially reduce the risk of concussion and other injuries
A study published in the Journal of Primary Prevention found that for every one-pound increase in neck strength, the odds of concussion decreased by 5%.
Implementing Safe Strength Training
When introducing strength training for youth athletes, it’s crucial to:
- Focus on proper technique rather than heavy weights
- Use age-appropriate exercises
- Ensure supervision by qualified coaches or trainers
- Gradually increase intensity and complexity of exercises
By addressing the issue of helmet weight and incorporating targeted strength training, youth football programs can potentially enhance player safety and performance.
The Cumulative Effect of Concussions
One of the most concerning aspects of concussions in youth sports is the increased vulnerability to subsequent injuries. Once a young athlete sustains a concussion, they become more susceptible to future concussions. This heightened risk is due to several factors:
- Brain Vulnerability: The brain is in a more vulnerable state following a concussion, making it more susceptible to further injury.
- Delayed Recovery: Young athletes may require longer recovery periods compared to adults.
- Subtle Symptoms: Subsequent concussions may occur with less force and present with more subtle symptoms, making them harder to detect.
Management and Recovery
Proper management of concussions is crucial for young athletes:
- Immediate Response: Any suspected concussion should result in immediate removal from play.
- Medical Evaluation: A thorough assessment by a healthcare professional is essential.
- Gradual Return: The return-to-play protocol typically involves a gradual reintroduction to physical activity.
- Cognitive Rest: Limiting mental exertion is as important as physical rest during recovery.
The Role of Baseline Cognitive Testing
An important tool in the proper assessment and management of concussions in youth sports is the implementation of baseline cognitive testing. This approach can be of great benefit in ensuring accurate diagnosis and appropriate return-to-play decisions.
What is Baseline Cognitive Testing?
Baseline cognitive testing involves assessing an athlete’s brain function before the sports season begins or prior to any injury. This test typically measures:
- Memory and recall
- Reaction time
- Information processing speed
- Problem-solving abilities
Benefits of Baseline Testing
The addition of baseline cognitive testing offers several advantages:
- Personalized Assessment: It provides a point of comparison specific to each athlete, allowing for more accurate post-injury evaluation.
- Objective Measurement: It offers objective data to complement subjective symptom reporting.
- Earlier Detection: Subtle changes in cognitive function can be identified, even when an athlete claims to be symptom-free.
- Informed Return-to-Play Decisions: Comparing post-injury test results to baseline helps ensure athletes don’t return to play prematurely.
Implementation in Youth Sports
Many schools and youth sports organizations are now incorporating baseline testing as part of their concussion management protocols. It’s recommended that these tests be conducted:
- Annually for younger athletes (due to rapid cognitive development)
- Every two years for older teens
- Before the start of each sports season for multi-sport athletes
Long-term Considerations
The potential long-term effects of concussions on young, developing brains are a significant concern. Research suggests that repeated concussions may lead to:
- Prolonged recovery times
- Increased risk of depression and anxiety
- Potential cognitive impairments
- Higher likelihood of future neurological issues
Conclusion
While concussions cannot be entirely prevented in youth sports, understanding the risks, implementing safety measures, and properly managing injuries when they occur are crucial steps in protecting young athletes. The increased vulnerability to subsequent concussions after an initial injury underscores the importance of careful monitoring and conservative management of these brain injuries in youth sports.By including baseline cognitive testing in concussion management strategies and staying informed about the latest research on protective equipment, healthcare providers, coaches, and parents can make more informed decisions about an athlete’s safety and readiness to return to play. This comprehensive approach to concussion management is essential for safeguarding the health and future of young athletes participating in sports.
References
Sport-related concussion: Evaluation and management. (n.d.). PMC – NCBI. Retrieved from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3959977/
SportsUnlimited.com. (n.d.). Football Helmet Buyers Guide. Retrieved from https://www.sportsunlimitedinc.com/football-helmet-buyers-guide.html
Collins, C. L., Fletcher, E. N., Fields, S. K., Kluchurosky, L., Rohrkemper, M. K., Comstock, R. D., & Cantu, R. C. (2014). Neck strength: a protective factor reducing risk for concussion in high school sports. The Journal of Primary Prevention, 35(5), 309-319.
HEADS UP to Youth Sports Coaches: Online Concussion Training. (2024). CDC. Retrieved from https://www.cdc.gov/heads-up/training/youth-sports.html
Concussion Epidemiology in Youth Sports: Sports Study of a Statewide High School Sports Program. (n.d.). PMC – NCBI. Retrieved from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7734362/
Consensus statement on concussion in sport: The 6th International Conference on Concussion in Sport. (2023). *British Journal of Sports Medicine, 57*(11), 695-703. https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/57/11/695
Haarbauer-Krupa, J., Register-Mihalik, J., Nedimyer, A. K., Chandran, A., Kay, M. C., Gilder, P., & Kerr, Z. (2020). Factors associated with concussion symptom knowledge and attitudes towards concussion care-seeking among parents of children aged 5-10 years. *Journal of Safety Research*. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsr.2021.05.003
Assessment of long-term effects of sports-related concussions. (2020). *Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation*. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7406890/
Kelshaw, P. M., Cook, N. E., Terry, D. P., Iverson, G. L., & Caswell, S. V. (2021). Child Sport Concussion Assessment Tool 5th Edition: Normative Reference Values in Demographically Diverse Youth. *Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine*.
Iverson, G. L., Cook, N. E., Howell, D. R., Collings, L. J., Kusch, C., Sun, J., Virji-Babul, N., & Panenka, W. J. (2021). Preseason Vestibular Ocular Motor Screening in Children and Adolescents. *Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine, 31*(4), e188–e192.
