Beyond the Symptoms: Disentangling Root Cause and Mechanism in Athletic Injuries

Beyond the Symptoms: Disentangling Root Cause and Mechanism in Athletic Injuries

Athletic injuries are an unfortunate reality, but our ability to prevent and effectively treat them hinges on a deeper understanding than just the immediate pain. We need to distinguish between the “why” and the “how”—the root cause and the mechanism of the injury. While intimately linked, these concepts offer different lenses through which to analyze and address athletic setbacks.

Our first article, “Beyond the Ache: Unearthing the Root Causes of Athletic Injuries,” focused on the pre-disposing factors that make an athlete vulnerable to injury. Our second, “Beyond ‘It Just Happened’: Unpacking the Mechanism of Athletic Injuries,” delved into the immediate events and forces that lead to tissue damage.

Let us break down their differences and then show how they combine to form a complete picture.

Root Cause: The “Why” – Pre-disposing Factors and Underlying Vulnerabilities

The root cause refers to the fundamental, often chronic, factors that increase an athlete’s susceptibility to injury over time. These are the conditions, imbalances, or practices that, if unaddressed, create fertile ground for injury to occur. As highlighted in “Beyond the Ache,” these include:

• Training Load Management: Inappropriate acute: chronic workload ratios, leading to under- or over-training (Gabbett, 2016).
• Biomechanical Imbalances: Muscle weaknesses, inflexibilities, or poor movement patterns (Powers, 2010; McConnell, 2013).
• Inadequate Recovery: Chronic fatigue from insufficient sleep, poor nutrition, or lack of rest days (Kellmann & Beckmann, 2018).
• Psychological Factors: High stress, anxiety, or poor coping mechanisms affecting physical readiness (Andersen & Williams, 2010).¹
• Environmental/Equipment Issues: Suboptimal playing surfaces or ill-fitting gear (Orchard & Fuller, 2010).
• Prior Injury: A history of previous injury often leaves residual vulnerabilities (Emery, 2010).

Key Characteristic of Root Causes: They are typically antecedent to the injury event. They set the stage, making an athlete more likely to encounter a situation where an injury mechanism can be triggered. Addressing root causes involve long-term strategies, such as periodized training, strength and conditioning, nutrition planning, and mental skills training.

Mechanism: The “How” – The Immediate Event of Tissue Damage

The mechanism of injury, as detailed in “Beyond ‘It Just Happened’,” describes the precise, acute biomechanical event that directly results in tissue damage.² It answers the question: what exact forces, movements, and body positions caused the tissue to fail at that moment in time?

• Specific Forces: Direct impact, shear, tension (stretch), compression, torsion (twisting).
• Body/Joint Position: The specific configuration of the limb or joint (e.g., valgus collapse of the knee, ankle inversion, hyperextension).
• Movement Direction and Speed: The direction of movement (e.g., rapid deceleration, sudden change of direction) and the velocity at which it occurred.
• Tissue Response: The immediate consequence of these forces on the tissue (e.g., muscle tears, ligament rupture, bone fracture).

Key Characteristic of Mechanisms: They are proximal causes; they are the immediate “trigger” that results in injury. Analyzing mechanisms often involves video analysis, detailed athlete accounts, and knowledge of sport-specific movements (Hewett et al., 2010; Myer et al., 2013).³

Comparing and Contrasting

Feature	Root Cause	Mechanism
Question	Why did the athlete get injured? What made them vulnerable?	How did the injury occur? What were the specific forces/movements?
Nature	Pre-disposing, underlying, often chronic factors.	Acute, immediate, biomechanical event.
Timing	Exists before the injury event, creating susceptibility.	Occurs at the moment of injury, directly causing tissue damage.
Focus	Vulnerabilities, imbalances, training practices, recovery, psychological state.	Specific joint positions, directions of force, tissue loading, movement patterns.
Examples	Hamstring strength deficit, chronic fatigue, rapid increase in training volume, poor landing technique.	High-speed eccentric contraction during sprinting leading to tears, non-contact valgus collapse causing ACL rupture.
Intervention	Long-term prevention strategies, foundational conditioning, lifestyle adjustments.	Acute injury management, immediate rehabilitation to restore function, sport-specific technique refinement.

The Combined Picture: From Vulnerability to Injury Event

The most powerful understanding of athletic injuries comes from integrating both concepts. A root cause makes an athlete susceptible, while the mechanism is the specific event that exploits that vulnerability.

Consider the example of a hamstring strain:

• Root Causes: An athlete might have a history of previous hamstring injuries (Emery, 2010), leading to residual weakness or scar tissue.⁴ They might also have a significant strength imbalance between their quadriceps and hamstrings, or inadequate eccentric hamstring strength (Mendiguchia & Brughelli, 2011). Furthermore, a sudden increase in sprint volume (poor training load management) could have contributed (Gabbett, 2016). These are the “whys” – the underlying reasons the hamstring was vulnerable.⁵
• Mechanism: During a high-speed sprint, in the late swing phase, the hamstring undergoes a rapid, forceful eccentric contraction as it tries to decelerate the lower leg.⁶ If the muscle’s capacity to withstand this specific load is exceeded due to the aforementioned root causes, the muscle fibers tear (Timmins et al., 2016). This specific “how” – the eccentric overload at high speed – is the mechanism.

Similarly for a non-contact ACL tear:

• Root Causes: An athlete might have weak hip abductors, leading to a predisposition for valgus collapse (Powers, 2010). They might also have poor neuromuscular control for landing or have experienced a recent spike in training intensity without adequate recovery (Myer et al., 2013; Gabbett, 2016). These are the underlying vulnerabilities.
• Mechanism: During a jump landing or sudden change of direction, the knee goes into excessive valgus collapse, internal tibial rotation, and possibly hyperextension, placing a critical multi-directional load on the ACL that exceeds its tensile strength, leading to rupture (Hewett et al., 2010). This precise sequence of movements and forces is the mechanism.

Conclusion: A Holistic Approach for True Prevention

Understanding both the root cause and the mechanism of athletic injuries is not merely academic; it is foundational for effective sports medicine.

• By identifying root causes, we can implement long-term, proactive prevention strategies that build resilient athletes and minimize susceptibility. This involves comprehensive strength and conditioning, proper periodization of training, meticulous recovery protocols, and addressing psychological well-being.
• By analyzing mechanisms, we can pinpoint the exact biomechanical failings that led to injury, allowing for precise rehabilitation strategies that correct faulty movement patterns and strengthen specific tissues for the demands of the sport. It also informs targeted technical coaching to avoid the high-risk movements.

---

References:

• Andersen, M. B., & Williams, J. M. (2010). Psychological factors and athletic injuries: Current perspectives. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 22(4), 393-405.
• Emery, C. A. (2010). Injury prevention and what is the role of sport and exercise for preventing disease and promoting health? British Journal of Sports Medicine, 44(1), 4-5.
• Gabbett, T. J. (2016). The training—injury prevention paradox: should athletes be training smarter and harder? British Journal of Sports Medicine, 50(5), 273-280.⁷
• Hewett, T. E., Myer, G. D., & Ford, K. R. (2010). Anterior cruciate ligament injuries in female athletes: Part 2: A meta-analysis of neuromuscular training programs. American Journal of Sports Medicine, 38(9), 1902-1911.
• Kellmann, M., & Beckmann, J. (2018). Recovery-stress in sport: From theory to practice. Routledge.
• McConnell, J. (2013). The physical therapist’s approach to the knee. In Orthopedic Knowledge Update: Sports Medicine 4 (pp. 53-64). American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons.
• Mendiguchia, J., & Brughelli, Y. (2011). A return-to-sport algorithm for acute hamstring injuries. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 45(7), 541-546.
• Myer, G. D., Sugimoto, D., Micheli, L. J., & Hewett, T. E. (2013). Young women’s sports-related ACL injuries: From research to prevention. Current Sports Medicine Reports, 12(5), 291-298.
• Orchard, J. W., & Fuller, C. W. (2010). Introduction to the ISJS injury surveillance supplement. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 44(7), 491-492.
• Powers, C. M. (2010). The influence of altered lower extremity kinematics on patellofemoral pain syndrome: A literature review. Journal of Orthopedic & Sports Physical Therapy, 40(2), 42-51.
• Timmins, R. G., Bourne, M. N., Shield, A. J., Williams, M. D., Lorenzen, C., & Opar, D. A. (2016).⁸ Short biceps femoris fascicles and hamstring injury in elite sprinters: a prospective cohort study. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 50(23), 1524-1529.